New collection project filters

We've just finished another round of updates for collection projects. A little over a month ago we announced some changes to collection and umbrella projects related to joining and displaying these newer projects on observation details pages. The updates being released today allow further customization of collection projects through the use of new types of filters.

Since launch, collection project managers have been able to specify multiple taxon, place, and user filters to limit which observations are shown in the project. Today we are allowing managers to specify the inverse of these filters. For example in the case of taxa, you could always create a taxon filter of Lepidoptera, and now you can "exclusion filter" for the taxon Papilionoidea. That would result in a project that shows observations of all Lepidoptera (moths and butterflies) except the Papilionoidea (butterflies) - effectively a project of moths.

It was possible to achieve this same outcome without exclusion filters, but you would have needed to create 42 taxon filters - one for each subfamily of Lepidoptera except Papilionoidea. With exclusion filters you only need to create 2 taxon filters - one for including Lepidoptera and one for excluding Papilionoidea.

These exclusion filters also apply to places (e.g. observations from the United States except California, Oregon, and Washington), and to users (e.g. observations from all users except these users).

Another new filter option for collection projects is annotation terms and values. Project managers can now choose to include observations which have annotations of a particular attribute (e.g. life stage), or a particular attribute and value (e.g life stage = adult). Currently there is a limit of one annotation filter per project, but this could be expanded over time to combine multiple filters, including an exclusion filter for annotations (e.g observations with a life stage = adult annotation, without a sex annotation).

We hope these new filters make it easier and faster to customize collection projects. As always we will continue to work on more improvements based on your feedback and we'll let you know when anything noteworthy is released.

Publicado el 03 de octubre de 2018 por pleary pleary

Comentarios

@klauswehrlin some of this functionality will come when we become a community, but it does not apply to projects: rather discuss these issues and others like it here: https://groups.google.com/forum/#!forum/inaturalist

Publicado por tonyrebelo hace más de 5 años

Thanks: this is really handy.
What I miss is the old style projects ability to compile a filter using a list. Such lists are needed for projects with the following species:
trees
climbers
succulents
bulbs
etc.
Typically such lists will be a mix of families (e.g. where all members are bulbs) and genera and species, and will tend to be very long (1000 species of trees, 2200 species of bulbs for southern Africa), so adding them via the filters above takes ages. But the lists are really efficient and useful.
Any chance that the new projects could include such lists?
(I especially like the way the batch tool that appends the lists to projects (or places or guides) checks the names and allows fixing)

I also note that my old projects with lists, cannot be converted to these new projects. That is a pity because I like the new style projects and would love to "modernize" them.

cf https://www.inaturalist.org/projects/nemba-prohibited-species-south-africa-1 with list: https://www.inaturalist.org/lists/1382657-NEMBA-Prohibited-Species--South-Africa--1s-Check-List?rank=species
versus a wannabe project that is just too much of a pain to set up:
https://www.inaturalist.org/projects/nemba-prohibited-species-south-africa

Publicado por tonyrebelo hace más de 5 años

Awesome. I hope we are able to do one that filters for fields too (or else make my Natural Community field an annotation :) )

Publicado por charlie hace más de 5 años

@eraskin will be very happy :)

Publicado por bouteloua hace más de 5 años

Woohoo! Excited to implement the annotations option. The exclusion filters also seem like a fantastic idea.

Publicado por eraskin hace más de 5 años

Can I do "must be observed in [place] or [place] or [place] EXCLUDING [bounding box]"? If so, I will be able to replace 60 individual location rules with 4 (or possibly just 2).

Publicado por eraskin hace más de 5 años

This is definitely a nice move. Customization is definitely useful and allows for a variety of applications to projects. I look forward to seeing this expand, of course, so hopefully this pilot for exclusions and annotation filters proves successful.

Publicado por jonathan142 hace más de 5 años

@tonyrebelo I agree, a list functionality would be great and it's something that's on the radar.

@eraskin only iNaturalist places can be used for Collection projects.

Publicado por tiwane hace más de 5 años

Very nice!

Publicado por alexanderr hace más de 5 años

Great addition!

There's another thing I'd really like to be able to filter for. I like to allow projects to include casual observations, but this results in the species lists making no sense because all zoo animals and house plants will be included. I would love a filter for Research Grade Qualification on projects, so you could f.e. exclude 'Organism is wild = No' , observations.

Publicado por stanvrem hace más de 5 años

@stanvrem - and I would love the opposite: Taxa in cultivation :: Organism is wild = 'No'

But I dont like that cultivated species are not research grade: they are as good data an any other!

Publicado por tonyrebelo hace más de 5 años

Thanks for implementing the exclusion feature which will benefits many Moth projects on iNat.

Publicado por gancw1 hace más de 5 años

Could the exclusion feature be easily programmed into the Compare and Identify pages? I'd love to (for example) be able to exclude all the ants when trying to ID a wasp. I know one can use URL manipulations, but it is a bit laborious.

Publicado por vynbos hace más de 5 años

Brilliant, thank you!

Publicado por karoopixie hace más de 5 años

These are some neat changes. I would like to echo the request to be able to upload a list of species from a file. I just set up a Collection for invasive species in Texas, and it would have taken much less time if there was a batch upload option. I do realize that I would still need to confirm each of my species names matches the taxa in iNat, but doing so all at once, without separate cut-pastes from my source files, would have been really handy.

Thank you for all that you iNat folks are doing to make this a program that I wholeheartedly recommend to everyone!

Publicado por aenglandbiol hace más de 5 años

@tonyrebelo - I set up four 'planted in ' projects for cultivated species - mainly to separate them from the wild species that we are looking for in our main collection projects. But I did it using the existing filters (casual + photo), agree it would be superior to be able to filter for 'not wild'. https://www.inaturalist.org/projects/planted-in-naturemap-countries

Publicado por lera hace casi 5 años

I add a project named "Lepidoptera of Karaman City"
Lepidoptera is an ORDO. In statistics I want to see the "FAMILIES" of this ORDO. I want to see how many species uploded of Lycaenidae or Noctuidae or Pieridae...
But in statistic menu there is plants bird mamals etc. It is unnecessary.
We need to manage statistics menu.
Regards.
https://www.inaturalist.org/projects/lepidoptera-of-karaman-city-turkiye?tab=stats

Publicado por ozgurkocak hace 7 meses

You want this:
https://www.inaturalist.org/lifelists/ozgurkocak?view=tree&tree_mode=full_taxonomy&taxon_id=47157
but for a place!

Request it on the forums?

At present, it is easiest to download all the data, select the family taxon field, and then in excel use pivot tables to summarize by family.
(e.g. https://www.inaturalist.org/observations/export?verifiable=any&place_id=any&projects=lepidoptera-of-karaman-city-turkiye - with field Taxon Extras :: "taxon_family_name" ticked.)

clunky: having it display on iNat will be far more efficient.

Publicado por tonyrebelo hace 7 meses

:) Thanks Tony.
Seems very good. I will try to understand it.
Best regards.

Publicado por ozgurkocak hace 7 meses

Agregar un comentario

Acceder o Crear una cuenta para agregar comentarios.
Vida Silvestre es una entidad asociada a la Organización Mundial de Conservación