Phase II Identifications.

Thank you everyone for participating in the City Nature Challenge 2024.

We have collected an amazing amount of data
93,008 observations by 2,711 observers.

And the loading is continuing: will we make 100,000 observations for southern Africa?

BUT, now comes the more arduous task: identifying all these observations. This must be completed within a week, so Sunday, May 5 is effective.
During the week, we will streamline the identification process, so please pop onto this umbrella journal and check the latest posts, which will include links to facilitate identification by taxonomic groups, regions, and categories.
It makes sense to pool our resources. We have less than 100 specialists, although lots more very keen and competent people, but we need to strategize for this huge workload.

Lots of people are still loading, so their priority is to get their observations on. Please try and complete it today or tomorrow (remember 1 May is a public holiday, so please work hard on the IDs). When done, they will almost certainly be helping with IDs.

Top priority now is to get identifications from Unknown, and vague, to at least Family level (or genus or species if you recognize it).

The tool we will use is the curation tool. It is really quick and efficient to use, but you will need to know how it works, or perhaps be reminded. Their is a 3 minute tutorial here: please take a moment to review it.:: https://vimeo.com/246153496

OK: here goes: please help us Identify the observations.

Please help with Identifications - Round 1:

Phase 1: Unknowns:

Phase 2: IDs above family: (You can filter further by adding your preferred group in the "search species" box)

FAQ:

  1. Q? I am a beginner, but would like to help. Where do I begin?
    A! Please start with the Unknowns (Phase 1) and identify them as well as you can.

  2. Q? I would like to stick to birds (or etc). What is the best way for me to help?
    A! Start with the Phase (2), click on your group (vertebrates), and in the "search species" box type birds and click to select and process the birds. When you have done all that you can, please go to Phase 1 and look for birds (or etc.) there.
    But remember: not all birds are in the "birds bin" yet for identification - more will come later.

  3. Q? I have identified those observations that I can, but there are lots that I cannot, and they get in the way. Is there a way of getting rid of them on my ID tool?
    A! Yes, when you have finished a page, and cannot identify those that remain, click the "Mark All as Reviewed" option, and they wont appear again (unless you select them by clicking the "reviewed" button).

  4. Q? What about Research Grade? We are only identifying them at a course level.
    A! We will check identifications to get them to research grade later in the week. Because that is more specialised, we want to clear the Unknowns and Vaguely Identified observations first and get basic identifications for as many observations as we can.

  5. Q? Wont we all be identifying the same unknowns?
    A! No - the filters on iNaturalist are really efficient, and once identified they will be removed from the queue. A very few might be identified twice, but that will help confirm them.

  6. Q? I am a keen gardener, and I want to help with garden plants. I like them best. How can I help?
    A! Please. They are also important because they attract pollinators, herbivores and other wild organisms in our gardens. Here are the planted observations that need attention. https://www.inaturalist.org/observations/identify?quality_grade=any%2Ccasual&project_id=city-nature-challenge-2024-southern-africa&verifiable=any&photos=true&place_id=any&page=5

  7. Q? I dont know a plant on the identifier, but it is unknown. Should I identify it as a plant?
    A! No! Just skip it - leave it for someone else to tackle. Identifications above Order for Invertebrates and Vertebrates are of limited value. If you know it is a fly or beetle (or even in insect), then please ID it as such. But for plants, if you cannot ID it to Family or finer, just skip it. You are wasting valuable time by making such a vague ID as "plant" or "dicot" or "monocot": to be most effective we need finer IDs, so just leave these for others who do recognize them.

Publicado el 30 de abril de 2024 por tonyrebelo tonyrebelo

Comentarios

Please join the project to get updates on our identification strategy.
https://www.inaturalist.org/projects/city-nature-challenge-2024-southern-africa/join (click!)

@traianbertau @alanhorstmann @peakaytea @galpinmd @sedgesrock @colin25 @dianastuder @sandraf @kenneth_oberlander @phaeoptilum @surfinbird @dinofelis @muhammad_a @damionjp @jaheymans @rion_c @capetonian_hiker @beetledude @herping_with_berks @lwnrngr @vandalsen @zoelj @magdastlucia @tjakie @dhjacobs @daverichardson @troos @hrodulf @sp_bester @tiaan_kotze @james_deacon @nwatinyoka @theoutdoorman102 @wingate @kareneichholz @ricky_taylor @galanhsnu @richardgill @qgrobler @alexiz @gabymeyer @camille247 @moxcalvitiumtorgos @terryrheeder @sstanton @alexdreyer @fynbos_adventures @seastung @pieterwinter @koekemoerm @carolinemashau @borisb @cliffdorse @penny21 @hildegard3 @dune_ninja @amestwooceans @tonyrebelo @rjpretor @janet_taylor @jeanramsay @inatural156 @michalsloviak @lumko @johnmanning @lotteryd @kyle_campbell1 @erwinsieben @petrabroddle @lezanne_rossouw @carasylvia @elena_ioganson @venturefoth @robertarcher397 @meganrose_f @carrynleigh @chewitt1 @konrad_k @christopher1201 @richyfourtytwo @kevinbalkwill @bgaudubon @outrampsjenny @onanymous @botswanabugs @jamesvanvuuren @simontamblyn @konrad-m-a-kaczmarek
@craigpeter @peacevaleconservancy @paolocandotti @dgr_rebecca @dgr_kermit @dgr_tbird @kyle_campbell1 @ish_crew @hendrikmc @leko_mkhize @erickmunro @jeremy1074 @hildegard3 @marietjie7 @michelle1853 @pdwhugo @phindile2 @siyabonga674 @prince_za @nshozi @cecileroux @botswanabugs @anelekhethwa @john8218 @stilbaai_herbarium @llewellyn_williams @richard_johnstone @taryniscool @erintc_96 @gemmapc @lumko @paddy51550 @diveinn_capetown @suncana @doreengail @hugh1 @ssmith2107 @melisa_nonjiko @hailey245 @lindalakeside @eted_ray @renatakruyswijk @margaretburger @lezanne_rossouw @fynbos_adventures @pieter_wouter @sunseed @dawn735 @nkarabeleng @varsha4 @nigelforshaw @amouton @kholeka3 @vcclarke @rianafourie @rslhaupt @jared103 @ricky_taylor @eted_shay @mr_t_explorer @dereksilberblatt @adele84 @winilemchunu @lihlechipeya @nomzamo_zamo @weries @ingrid_schudel @alienwatch @lmossop @kaylaknight @thembelihlejali @esi_bossman @camille247 @carol_martin @angelica_rhoda @sthembisorh @naledi1 @van_zyl_family @cdzerefos

Publicado por tonyrebelo hace alrededor de 1 mes

Status 10am on Tuesday 30 April

Phase 1: Unknowns:

Unknowns: 23,401 observations needing identification.

Phase 2: IDs above family:

Plants: 2,038 observations needing identification.
Invertebrates: 1,368 observations needing identification.
Fungi : 553 Observations needing identification.
Vertebrates: 264 observations needing identification.

Publicado por tonyrebelo hace alrededor de 1 mes

Working thru the Unknowns from 26 April ...

Publicado por dianastuder hace alrededor de 1 mes

I noticed there are a few hundred more observations from the region under:
"City Nature Challenge 2024: Global Project"
such a split may be general, because I did find a similar number of "unknowns" yesterday, continent by continent (cannot believe only southern Africa has done so much extra).

Publicado por borisb hace alrededor de 1 mes

. . . found true.
https://www.inaturalist.org/observations/identify?quality_grade=any%2Ccasual&project_id=182602&verifiable=any&photos=true&place_id=any
(2024: Canadian project branch) displays 83 pages to ID, while only two are found under "global project".

Publicado por borisb hace alrededor de 1 mes

Is there a way to separate them into Summer and Winter Rainfall or into provinces? - I tried to insert Mpumalanga as a filter, but it would not take.

Publicado por kevinbalkwill hace alrededor de 1 mes

Many of motobatsi's posts are blank. Please will someone who knows how help him fix them. My computer takes a long time to open . . . . . nothing!!

Publicado por kevinbalkwill hace alrededor de 1 mes
Many of motobatsi's posts are blank. Please will someone who knows how help him fix

@kevinbalkwill You can leave a comment on his observations: that will notify them.

@suvarna - please followup

Publicado por tonyrebelo hace alrededor de 1 mes

@borisb
Thanks so much I forgot. I have added these to our project. They will now be included (and extra 1,100 observations at this stage).

https://www.inaturalist.org/projects/city-nature-challenge-2024-southern-africa-extras

Yes: we have several cities that woke up to late to register, but who still wanted to take part. Montagu, Agulhas and West Coast feature prominently.

Publicado por tonyrebelo hace alrededor de 1 mes

Perhaps there needs to be some education on Quality vs Quantity before efforts like this. One has to do a LOT of WADING through out of focus, sterile, in the garden, in the brickwork dross to see one or two gems.

Publicado por kevinbalkwill hace alrededor de 1 mes

You can skip the Unknowns and move to a narrower group which is pre-sorted ?

Publicado por dianastuder hace alrededor de 1 mes

@kevinbalkwill - we use the CNC for recruitment, and the train observers up for the GSB, which is more monitoring. This is the investment in students, some of which will make the cut for PhDs ...
Of course, the quality of the CNC depends on how much training the coordinates did beforehand, but generally the emphasis is on getting new recruits.

Publicado por tonyrebelo hace alrededor de 1 mes

Status 20:00 on Wednesday 01 May

Phase 1: Unknowns:

Unknowns: 20,261 observations needing identification. (13% done) down 3,200

Phase 2: IDs above family:

Plants: 2,645 observations needing identification. up 600
Invertebrates: 1,657 observations needing identification. up 290
Fungi : 750 Observations needing identification. up 200
Vertebrates: 366observations needing identification. up 120

Publicado por tonyrebelo hace alrededor de 1 mes

"Many of motobatsi's posts are blank. Please will someone who knows how help him fix"
@vats, who is the current champion for Umzimvubu? I noticed Nicky hasn't participated. @motobatsi needs to fix his observations please

Publicado por suvarna hace alrededor de 1 mes

Status 09:00 on Thursday 02 May

Phase 1: Unknowns:

Unknowns: 18,981 observations needing identification. (13% done) down 1,280

Phase 2: IDs above family:

Plants: 3,080 observations needing identification. up 360
Invertebrates: 1,750 observations needing identification. up 100
Fungi : 780 Observations needing identification. up 30
Vertebrates: 395observations needing identification. up 30

Publicado por tonyrebelo hace alrededor de 1 mes

progress now moved to Phase II ....

Publicado por tonyrebelo hace 30 días

Agregar un comentario

Acceder o Crear una cuenta para agregar comentarios.
Vida Silvestre es una entidad asociada a la Organización Mundial de Conservación